What Makes a Great Podcast Guest? Hosts Share Their Secrets

Want to get invited back? Or turn a one-time interview into new opportunities?

We asked real podcast hosts what makes a guest stand out. Whether you’re new to guesting or a seasoned pro, these tips will help you be the kind of guest hosts love.

1. “They’ve Actually Listened to My Show”
“When a guest mentions a past episode or asks about a theme I care about, I know they’re invested. It instantly sets the tone.” – Business podcast host, UK

Takeaway: Do your homework. Listen to 1–2 episodes, note the style, and reference it during the convo.

2. “They Show Up With a Story, Not Just a Bio”
“I want more than credentials, I want moments. Vulnerable, weird, funny, true stories that listeners will remember.” – Lifestyle podcaster, US

Takeaway: Come with 2–3 short stories that illustrate your topic. Stories stick bios don’t.

3. “They Make It a Conversation, Not a Monologue”
“Great guests don’t dominate. They ask questions back, they riff. It’s a vibe thing.” – Host, Australia

Takeaway: Treat the interview like a chat, not a pitch. Flow > script.

4. “They Share the Episode Like a Partner Would”
“The best guests promote it. They post it, email it, tag us. It makes all the difference.” – Wellness Podcast Host, US

Takeaway: Share the episode widely. It helps the host, builds your brand, and creates goodwill.

Pro Tip: Your Podcast Nest profile should reflect these strengths. Make it easy for hosts to say yes. Strong bio, topic ideas, and a link to past episodes help build trust fast.